Fine Then features Hugh J. Noble (Slum Summer, Seance Weather) and Andrew Fitzgerald, who also plays in Bat Lords, and puts out his own music as Mr. Nobody and Biding Time.
Their album Could It Be Magic? No, released in February 2022, features guest contributions from Jacquie Bazinet (The Fictitious Dishes, Sleepy Hollow) and Sean Con (Bat Lords). According to Hugh J. Noble, "The sound references John Carpenter's soundtrack work, sad boy pop punk, Haircut 100 style synthpop, Jesu-esque dronery, and several points in between. There's a weird Heaven's Gate influenced website and a couple of DIY music videos online." The videos are for "I Saw the Light, and it Looked a Lot Like an Existential Crisis" and "Nothingness Itself (feat Sean Con)."